Chapter 14 - Beth Makes Her Choice
The envelope contained a photocopied letter purportedly written by Beth.
It described Rachel as controlling and accused us of preventing Carol from seeing the children without justification.
At the bottom was another signature resembling Beth's, only worse.
My sister read it over video call and went pale.
“She's doing it again,” Beth said.
“What do you mean again?”
Beth hesitated.
When she was seventeen, Mom had drafted a letter withdrawing Beth from a summer art program.
She'd signed Beth's name and told the organizers the family was dealing with a private crisis.
Beth discovered the truth only after her place had been given to someone else.
“I thought it was one terrible decision,” she said.
“I didn't think she'd do it to you.”
I wanted to tell her she should have warned me.
Then I remembered all the times I'd dismissed Beth's anger toward Mom as ordinary sibling resentment.
We had both been trained to treat our own experiences as isolated incidents.
“I'm sorry I never asked what really happened,” I said.
Beth wiped her eyes.
“I'm sorry I helped you believe she was just strict.”
She offered to write a statement confirming that she had not signed either document.
We agreed she should use her own words and have an independent professional advise her before submitting anything.
Later that day, Mom called Beth and offered her a choice.
Take Carol's side publicly, or lose access to the family's heirloom jewelry and holiday gatherings.
Beth said she'd give up the jewelry.
Mom responded by telling Connor and Tyler that their mother was destroying the family.
This time, Beth didn't argue in front of the boys.
She ended the call and held them close.
Then she sent our extended family a short correction identifying the letters as unauthorized.
No insults.
No private stories.
Just a fact Mom couldn't comfortably explain.
Within minutes, relatives began calling.
Some apologized.
Others demanded that Beth stop embarrassing her mother.
Beth switched off her phone.
Grandpa called me that evening with news I hadn't expected.
He had found a message Carol sent to Linda months before Christmas.
It referred to the upcoming holiday as an opportunity to put Austin back in his place.
This hadn't been invented at the airport.
The plan had been growing for weeks.
Then Beth sent me one final screenshot.
Mom had written to a cousin: Once Austin signs the acknowledgment, I'll let the children have their gifts.
There was an attachment.
It was a document titled Parental Cooperation Agreement.
May you like
And the first sentence declared that Rachel and I acknowledged Carol's authority to discipline our children during all future family visits.
